Czech Hotels Travel :: A History of Slovakia, Second Edition: The Struggle for Survival


A History of Slovakia, Second Edition: The Struggle for Survival

A History of Slovakia, Second Edition: The Struggle for Survival
List Price: $19.95
Czech Hotels Travel Price: $13.57
Your Savings: $ 6.38 ( 32% )
Subject To Change Without Notice
Availability: Usually ships in 10 to 12 days
Manufacturer: Palgrave Macmillan
Average Customer Rating: Average rating of 3.0/5Average rating of 3.0/5Average rating of 3.0/5Average rating of 3.0/5Average rating of 3.0/5

Buy it now at Amazon.com!

Binding: Paperback
Dewey Decimal Number: 943.73
EAN: 9781403969293
ISBN: 1403969299
Label: Palgrave Macmillan
Manufacturer: Palgrave Macmillan
Number Of Items: 1
Number Of Pages: 416
Publication Date: 2005-06-04
Publisher: Palgrave Macmillan
Release Date: 2005-05-19
Studio: Palgrave Macmillan

Related Items

Editorial Reviews:

This classic book offers the most comprehensive and up-to-date history of Slovakia, from its establishment on the Danubian Plain to the present. While paying tribute to Slovakia's resilience and struggle for survival, it describes contributions to European civilization in the Middle Ages; the development of Slovak consciousness in response to Magyarization; its struggle for autonomy in Czechoslovakia after the Treaty of Versailles; its resistance, as the first Slovak Republic, to a Nazi-controlled Europe; its reaction to Communism; and the path that led to the creation of the second Slovak Republic. Now fully updated to the present day, the book examines the vagaries of Slovak post-Communist politics that led to Slovakia's membership in NATO and the European Union.



Spotlight customer reviews:

Customer Rating: Average rating of 2/5Average rating of 2/5Average rating of 2/5Average rating of 2/5Average rating of 2/5
Summary: selective historical nationalism
Comment: This book had a shocking and noticeable bias that can be summed up as nationalistic history. Although this is one of the few books on Slovak history, it was disturbing to read as the author sugar coated the Nazi collaboration under Josef Tiso in the Chapter "The Slovak Republic, 1939-1945", as if the goal of national self-determination justified his actions during this time period.

Customer Rating: Average rating of 2/5Average rating of 2/5Average rating of 2/5Average rating of 2/5Average rating of 2/5
Summary: disappointing but could have been worse
Comment: Being curious about Central European history, I went ahead and read this book despite the mixed reviews on Amazon. After reading it, I do tend to agree with some of the reviewers and feel a bit disappointed. It being written by a non-historian does detract from its value. In addition, a troublesome aspect is that the book's underlying theme is the Slovaks' survival. In other words the ancestors of modern Slovaks were guided by striving toward achieving independence of "Slovakia / Slovensko" since the arrival of the Hungarians in the 10th century. This idea projects 19th century sensibilities of national identity or nationalism onto the early Middle Ages. As Kirschbaum's specialty is politics, this supposed book of Slovak history works on trying to relate past political events to Slovak nationalism and the creation of Slovakia.

In the end I found Kirschbaum's underlying messages of "pity the Slovaks" and "the Slovaks had to fight for their right to live from the beginning" (that dubious projection of 19th century sensibilities onto the distant past) to be tiresome after a while. For a supposed history book, his apologist's stance and whitewashing when discussing the Slovak puppet state in World War Two was also disappointing and a sign that his ancestry / national allegiance was affecting his analysis of historical events. He would have done better if he had followed the approach used by Ivo Goldstein in his book on Croatian history (Unlike Kirschbaum, Goldstein had no problem with describing and analyzing unsavory or less attractive events in his people's history. Then again, Goldstein is a historian whereas Kirschbaum is not).

I give two stars because it isn't a complete disaster but adjust your expectations when reading this one. It could have been much better if it had provided more comprehensive treatment of events on Slovak territory regardless of whether they suited Kirschbaum's pet theories / theses on Slovak nation-building.

Customer Rating: Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5
Summary: Thick growth of trees, no forest
Comment: Over the last century or so, a large number of nations have become sovereign entities, recognized by others, members of the United Nations, with flag, airline, World Cup football team, and anthem. These range from Tuvalu and St. Lucia to Nigeria, Vietnam, and Kazakhstan. Everyone knows that there are others, equally deserving of such recognition, that don't achieve it. Kurdistan is a prime example; Tibet, Chechnya, Euskadi, and national states for Native Americans come to mind too. It is interesting to ponder on the historical currents or maybe even accidents that determine whether or not a nation comes into existence. Slovakia's history could serve as a prime example. Never really a nation on its own, the Slovak people endured a millennium of Hungarian rule, only---on coming close to national recognition---to be subsumed for another seven decades into Czechoslovakia, in which country they played perpetual second fiddle. This history could have been written around such a question---why some and not others ? It was not.

Nineteenth century nationalism may have led to the creation of many national states, particularly in Europe, it led to the demise of colonialism, but it has played a negative role in the world also. The "us against the world" mentality, atavistic tribalism, and xenophobia have all been encouraged and used by nationalistic forces. Nationalistic history thus can play either positive or negative roles . I would say that THE HISTORY OF SLOVAKIA is such a nationalistic book, though to be fair, a few attempts are made to show more balance. Granted, if you want to know the history of that small Central European country (people) in English, I think you will have to read Kirschbaum's name and date-studded work. But beware. By calling the book "history of Slovakia", the author may be `creating' an entity that never really existed until the late 19th century.

The history of the Great Moravian Empire of the 9th century is highly speculative---at such a remote distance in time, how can we be sure that it had anything to do with modern Slovaks ? Slavs, yes. It plays the role of that "original root" which every nation tends to find, whether it actually existed or not. Kirschbaum himself questions some of the Slovak historiography, for instance, a claim that Matthew Cak, in the 14th century, was a Slovak ruler or hero. Perhaps he was just another powerful Hungarian landlord. We read about the Slovak national awakening in the 19th century, the separation of the Slovak lands from Hungary and joining with Bohemia and Moravia to form the first Czechoslovak republic (to 1938), the subsequent re-amalgamation from 1948 to 1989, and the ultimate "Velvet Divorce" in 1993, after which Slovakia finally achieved nationhood. It is the section on the period 1939-1945, when Slovakia was a German puppet state in Central Europe, that seemed ambiguous and dubious. It is a whitewash of collaborators with the Nazis. The mantra is "The regime may not have been palatable to everybody, but it protected the country and provided the conditions for the expression of national aspirations." At the same time, over two-thirds of the Jewish citizens were exterminated. National aspirations indeed ! "Slovaks proved that they were able to govern themselves." (p.211) A spurious claim as Slovakia lay under the German thumb. Slovaks never attacked anyone--just a `symbolic' two divisions sent into the Soviet Union along with the Wehrmacht. This is nationalistic history. It is written to "identify all the trees", but we don't see the forest. I'm sorry. I'd like to read a more balanced view.


Customer Rating: Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5
Summary: A scholarly work
Comment: Being interested in the history of my people, I was happy that
someone undertook this subject. I can now appreciate even more
their struggles and happily their survival as a people despite
over 1,00O years of oppression by their neighbors.

Customer Rating: Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5
Summary: Overview of Nation-building/ Survival in a Volatile Region
Comment: My desire to learn about this obscure Central European country over-rode my hesitancy ... a hesitancy which stemmed from potentially being over-whelmed with names, dates, and historical events of which I knew litte. Not being a historical buff yet wanting to learn, I forged ahead. Fortunately, the writing style of the author allayed my concerns with the first few chapters which set the pace for a comfortable reading experience.

Starting at the beginning, Greater Moravia was the region's name in the 900s (A.D) which was a vassal of the German Frankish empire. The Slavic nobles and people resented this relationship from which territorial disputes arose along with new winners. The area was called Pannonia under the Roman Empire. In 907 A.D. the Magyar tribes conquered the ruling German Franks. The Magyars settled in the region, having an intimate relationship with the Slovaks until the 20th century. Of note, the Slovaks maintained their Slavic language and culture despite this apparent and at times very real domination by another people. Under the Magyars, there was a form of autonomy allowing the separate culture to propigate. Numerous monarchs rose to power and forged political alliances adding to the volatility of the region. The future survival of both Hungary and Slovakia were placed constantly at risk. The author does a superb job of describing political decisions and alliances which affected the direction of the future -- which form the basis of current events. During the Middle Ages, various wars with the Germans and Mongolian invaders eventually brought the reigning Hungarian monarchs to the forefront of both countries. The Ottoman victory in Mohacs, Hungary in 1526 led to the partition of Hungary. Under conditions of this defeat, the Hapsburg monarchy with its absolutist policies, rose to rule over the Hungarians and Slovaks. Catholicism attempted to limit effects of the Reformation and its open ideas toward religion and education which spread despite opposition. While the Slovak political history mirrored that of the Hungarians, the differences in language and culture developed side by side rather peacefully for approximately 800 - 900 years. However, the revolutionary years of the late 1840s changed that. When the Magyars became more nationalistic, the Slovaks became marginalized which forced them to yearn for and develop a foundation for a country of their own. The book does a highly credible job in describing the creation of Czechoslovakia and the international milieu in which this major world event occured. The social, economic, and political policies of the 1930s and 1940s up until World War II are well discussed. The rise of Communism post World War II mimics that of the other defeated nations in Central and Eastern Europe. Kirschbaum states it best, "they became trapped in the bipolar struggle between the Western liberal democratic world and the eastern proletarian Communist one." [p.231] The defeat of Communism, from the ashes of which arose ... a separate country, called Slovakia ... is one of the major success stories of modern times in Europe.

This book is highly recommended reading for anyone who has an interest in the politics of Central Europe and how struggles for domination affected the region. It would also be of interest to anyone who has roots and family ties to the area. The book is a well written scholarly document that includes a detailed and lengthy bibliography for each chapter. Anyone wanting to verify facts, delve deeper into the subject or pursue their own research is given a map to reach their destination. Erika Borsos (erikab93)



Buy it now at Amazon.com!


Czech Trips Books

Czech Trips DVD

Czech Trips Softwares

Czech Trips Magazines

Czech Posters

Czech Art Prints


Czech Travel 2008 Calendars


2008 Monthly Calendars


Czech Hotels Travel Special Resources
Czech Arts
Czech Entertainment
Czech Government
Czech Business
Czech Culture
Czech Education
Czech Health
Czech Map
Sports & Recreation
Travel & Tourism
Food and Recipes
Czech Festivals
Czech Hotels
Czech Museums
Czech Transportation


Czech Destinations
Prague, Czech
Brno, Czech
Plzen, Czech


Czech Hotels
Prague Hotels
Brno Hotels
Praha Hotels




Czech Hotels Travel | About | Ads | Contact | Terms of Use | Czech Resources | Czech Hotels Travel Site Directory

Czech Hotels Travel
Maintained by: Marketer Solutions | Link Building